In 1983, neuroscientist Benjamin Libet published an experiment that put a very familiar human claim in some difficulty. Volunteers were asked to move a wrist whenever they wished and to report the moment at which they became conscious of wanting to move. In one set of trials, the brain activity associated with preparing the movement had begun about 350 milliseconds before the reported intention. So the brain was already preparing to act, and the person had not yet reported deciding.
This summary is AI-generated. Please read the full article for complete understanding.
Originally published in Times Now on 6 November '26
In 1983, neuroscientist Benjamin Libet published an experiment that put a very familiar human claim in some difficulty. Volunteers were asked to move a wrist whenever they wished and to report the moment at which they became conscious of wanting to move. In one set of trials, the brain activity associated with preparing the movement had begun about 350 milliseconds before the reported intention. So the brain was already preparing to act, and the person had not yet reported deciding.
Does this mean there is no free will? That would be going too far. Moving a wrist is hardly the same thing as making an important decision in life. Besides, what that electrical activity signifies is itself disputed. In 2012, Aaron Schurger and colleagues suggested that the preparatory signal could arise from accumulated neural fluctuations rather than a decision already taken unconsciously. A 2019 study by Uri Maoz and colleagues found the signal for arbitrary movements but not for more consequential choices. In 2025, Guillaume Pech and colleagues, working with different tasks, found a stronger signal for rewarded than unrewarded decisions. Even the timing of reported conscious intention is contested. Neuroscience has not established whether our decisions are ultimately free of causation.




