Someone asks how we are, and we say, “I am so good. I’m doing so well.” Then comes 3 a.m., and we know better. Nobody outside can check that claim, so the talk says an inner claim can be falsified only in the first person. Science runs on peer review; self-inquiry does not. A mirror can show where we stand, but whether we accept what it shows depends on honesty. Which of our own claims have we never allowed to be tested?
This summary is AI-generated. Please read the full article for complete understanding.
[From a conversation between Acharya Prashant and Prof. Prathosh, an artificial intelligence researcher at IISc, 2026. This part begins with why definitions settle nothing, then asks whether “I exist” and “I suffer” can be the starting points of Vedanta, and whether self-inquiry can be verified or falsified.]
Prof. Prathosh: I keep telling my students always that most philosophical discussions, just like most physics discussions, end up being discussions on math, ’cause you start defining what terms are. You know, for instance, people often ask me, has AGI arrived and is there a consciousness and so on. As an engineer, I would always answer them saying that there is no one agreed-upon definition of what AGI is. So if something has no definition, there’s no point in actually discussing whether it has come out or not.
Acharya Prashant: But Vedant doesn’t deal with definitions. Vedant deals with the one who is at the centre of all definitions, the definition maker. The I, the self, the little self, the ego. So I can keep changing my definitions to, you know, suit my needs or comfort or convenience, but I still remain unfulfilled. No definition brings me to completion.




