On YouTube
A Westerner's take on Indian chaos || Acharya Prashant, in conversation (2022)
10.2K views
3 years ago
Upanishads
Vedanta
Order and Disorder
Spirituality vs. Religion
Self-Knowledge
Doership
East vs. West
Carefree vs. Careless
Description

Acharya Prashant addresses a seeker's observation about the contrast between India's profound spiritual scriptures and its chaotic reality. He explains that the common person in India is largely disconnected from the country's spiritual heritage, with most having not even heard the word 'Upanishad,' let alone understood its teachings. He notes that the ordinary cab driver would not have a spiritual attitude towards life. Acharya Prashant then contrasts the Western and Eastern approaches to life and order. The West, he explains, relies heavily on the self and the ego. The ego reigns supreme, and the belief is that one must do everything for oneself. This leads to the establishment of man-made order and systems. In the West, being responsible for oneself means being a lonely individual in a vast world, which can lead to fear, violence, and a hard, empathyless internal stiffness. This order is based on discipline born from fear of penalty. In contrast, the East's spiritual heritage, particularly Vedanta, has a different perspective. It acknowledges a higher, divine order beyond man's will. This higher order is not an external God but the inner Self, the Atma. The spiritual path is about surrendering to this inner reality, which the saints referred to as 'Ram' or 'Truth'. This surrender leads to a state of being carefree, not careless. Being carefree means assigning care to the highest within you, which is the Atma. This is different from the Western concept of individuality, which is about fragmentation and isolation. In Vedanta, individuality means becoming indivisible by dissolving into the whole. The speaker concludes that the West's focus on objectivity and the observable world, while creating material order, misses the subjective reality of the observer, the Self. This makes self-knowledge more difficult for a Westerner to grasp.